Skip to content

Utilities are unavoidable expenses for business owners. Selecting the right energy source for your company is an important decision that directly affects daily operations and your bottom line. Each business has unique energy needs, so this decision profoundly influences your operational efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and environmental impact. Electricity and natural gas stand out as the two most popular sources powering commercial spaces. By gaining a better understanding of these prominent energy sources, you can find the right plan that best suits your company’s needs.

Understanding Electricity as an Energy Source

Electricity is one of the most versatile and popular energy sources because it can be used to power just about every aspect of your business – from general lighting and heating to electronics and appliances. Electricity is generated by power plants from a variety of resources like non-renewable fossil fuels and nuclear energy as well as renewable sources like solar and wind power. This wide spectrum of electricity generating resources make it incredibly accessible for commercial operations. 

Advantages of Electric Energy

Electric energy offers a wealth of benefits. Firstly, electricity is notably clean and environmentally friendly, especially when sourced from renewables like solar or wind power. The availability of renewable options empowers businesses to reduce their carbon footprint while emphasizing sustainability efforts. Electricity also boasts high energy efficiency, minimizing energy waste to help your business save money. Additionally, electricity is highly available with a robust infrastructure, ensuring a reliable supply. It is a very versatile form of power that is well-suited for diverse operations.

Disadvantages of Electric Energy

Electric energy has some notable disadvantages as well. One significant drawback is electric energy’s dependence on a centralized power grid that is vulnerable to disruptions like extreme weather conditions or cyberattacks. Due to this reliance, businesses can be susceptible to power outages and blackouts, disrupting operations and leading to financial losses. Another challenge is fluctuating energy costs. Electricity prices are subject to market fluctuations and regulatory changes, posing challenges for small business budgets. 

Exploring Natural Gas as an Energy Source

Natural gas, a versatile and widely used energy source, is a fossil fuel composed primarily of methane. The extraction process begins beneath the earth’s surface with drilling or hydraulic fracturing (fracking) to access underground reservoirs of natural gas. Once extracted, the raw gas undergoes a crucial purification process. Afterwards, natural gas is ready to be transported through an extensive network of pipelines to reach homes and businesses. Natural gas is particularly popular as it is the cleanest burning fossil fuel, serving as a reliable and efficient source of commercial power.

Advantages of Natural Gas

Natural gas is a compelling choice for businesses due to several benefits. Firstly, natural gas is abundant and widely available, making it a dependable power source for a variety of industries. In comparison to other fossil fuels, natural gas produces significantly lower emissions, helping businesses reduce their environmental impact. Due to its pipeline infrastructure, natural gas is also highly reliable and consistent, even during extreme weather conditions. Furthermore, natural gas is cost-effective and can help businesses reduce their energy expenses, making it a popular commercial energy choice.

Disadvantages of Natural Gas

Natural gas does come with certain drawbacks for consideration. One major concern is the environmental impact of natural gas production. While burning natural gas is far cleaner than other fossil fuels, the extraction process does include the emission of methane gas that contributes to climate change. Additionally, infrastructure requirements for implementing natural gas power can be extensive and require costly upgrades. The price of natural gas is also subject to market fluctuations that can affect business budgets and planning. The final consideration is that the dependence on a finite fossil fuel raises concerns about long-term sustainability and energy security.

Electricity vs. Natural Gas: Factors to Consider

Energy Costs

Electric energy and natural gas have distinct pricing structures and cost considerations. Generally speaking, the cost of natural gas is typically less expensive than electric power, however initial installation costs are higher. While electricity is inexpensive and easy to install, the consumption costs of electric energy tend to be more expensive.

When it comes to utility bills, electric energy pricing often involves a mix of fixed and variable rates, with options for time-of-use and renewable sources. Short-term costs can fluctuate due to market dynamics. In contrast, natural gas pricing is based on consumption, with fluctuating short-term costs influenced by supply and demand. It’s essential to weigh the installation costs against average energy rates to determine the right choice for your business. 

Environmental Impact

Assessing the environmental impact of energy sources is an important consideration. Electric energy has a significantly lower carbon footprint and lower greenhouse gas emissions when compared to natural gas, especially when sourced from renewables like solar or wind energy. In contrast, natural gas is cleaner than other fossil fuels, however extraction and processing releases greenhouse gases, contributing to climate change.

The integration of renewable energy in the electrical grid contributes to cleaner energy generation. Businesses can utilize the power of solar, wind, or geothermal energy for their operations while contributing to a healthier environment. Biogas, a renewable natural gas alternative created from organic waste, is gaining prominence, however it is not universally available due to limited resources and processing facilities. Ultimately, businesses will find that electricity, especially from renewable sources, is the more environmentally friendly choice.

Energy Efficiency and Dependability

Generally speaking, natural gas appliances and heating systems are more energy efficient than electric energy alternatives. That being said, electrical energy can be easily improved through efficiency measures like management systems or smart grids. When it comes to reliability, the electrical grid is much more susceptible to power outages and blackouts due to extreme weather conditions. Businesses using electric energy may need to implement a redundant system to ensure uninterrupted supply. Natural gas pipelines are underground, ensuring more reliable power during extreme conditions.

Infrastructure and Availability

Electric energy benefits from a widespread availability advantage due to the United States’ extensive electrical grid system. The easily accessible grid also enables fairly straightforward expansion and upgrade opportunities, empowering more areas to adopt renewable energy sources as they become available. On the contrary, the complex infrastructure of natural gas limits it’s availability. Natural gas pipelines are not universally present across the country. Attempts to expand or upgrade this infrastructure are complicated, requiring significantly more investment and planning to accommodate increased demand. 

Case Studies: Electricity and Natural Gas Solutions

Case Study 1: Electric HVAC Solutions For Ebensburg’s Cambria Building

The Cambria building, located in Ebensburg, Pennsylvania, needed to replace their failing HVAC system as it couldn’t keep up with the demands of the building. In order to determine the best solution for their needs, they completed a cost analysis for 7 different HVAC systems that utilized various energy sources. Their analysis concluded that an electric-powered ground-source heat pump would be the most cost-effective solution to meet their needs. This system uses a small amount of electric energy to extract solar energy stored in the ground, reducing their emissions by 77%. While this system had the most expensive installation costs, their projections found that a ground-source heat pump system would save the building $500,000 over a 25 year period.

Case Study 2: Natural Gas Supports Growth at Rochestown Park Hotel 

Rochestown Park Hotel is a popular hotel for tourists visiting Cork, Ireland. In 2008, they completed a $19 million renovation to expand their hotel by 50 guest rooms, a new bar and restaurant, and expanding the reception area. This massive project caused a significant increase in energy demand that their previous heating system couldn’t support. As a solution, Rochestown Park upgraded to a natural gas combined heat and power system (CHP) to meet their new energy demands without increasing their carbon footprint. Since installation, the hotel has benefitted from more reliable heating with much lower carbon emissions and annual cost savings of over $130,000. The success of this new system empowered the Hotel to upgrade the system to accommodate summer cooling capabilities.

Choosing the Best Energy Source for your Business

Ultimately, the best energy source for your business comes down to personal preference. Electric energy and natural gas both have unique advantages and disadvantages. Consider your business’s specific needs, goals, and environmental commitments to make a well-informed decision. Integrity Energy is happy to guide you through this complicated process. Whether your goals are reducing carbon emissions, lowering utility bills, or finding the most reliable power for your business, our representatives are dedicated to helping you navigate this complex industry and find the most cost-effective energy solutions for your needs and goals. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are the primary differences between electricity and natural gas as energy sources?

A: Electricity is a versatile source generated from a variety of renewable and nonrenewable resources. Natural gas is a highly reliable source generated from nonrenewable methane gas. Homes and businesses receive electricity through power lines whereas underground pipelines transport natural gas. natural gas is transported through underground pipelines. 

Q: How are electric and natural gas energy costs determined?

A: Electric energy pricing often involves a mix of fixed and variable rates, with options for time-of-use and renewable sources. Natural gas pricing is based on consumption. Both energy costs are prone to fluctuations based on supply and demand. 

Q: Can I switch between electric and natural gas if my energy needs change?

A: Yes, however switching energy sources may require structural adjustments and careful consideration of your current energy plan to determine the cost-effectiveness and environmental impact of making the change.

Q: What are the environmental impacts of electricity and natural gas?

A: Generally speaking, electricity has a lower carbon footprint, especially when sourced from renewables like solar or wind power. While natural gas is the cleanest burning fossil fuel, it does contribute to greenhouse gas emissions during extraction and processing.

Q: Is it possible to use a combination of electricity and natural gas in my business?

A: Yes, it’s possible to use a combination of sources, allowing you to optimize energy use based on your business’s operational needs and budget.

Q: Are there any government regulations or policies that affect the choice between electricity and natural gas?

A: Yes, government regulations and policies, such as environmental regulations and incentives for renewable energy, can influence the choice between electricity and natural gas for businesses.

Q: How can I evaluate the energy efficiency of my business to determine the best energy source?

A: You can evaluate the energy efficiency of your business by conducting an energy audit, assessing consumption patterns, and considering energy-efficient technologies to determine the best energy source based on your needs and goals.

Q: What factors should I consider when comparing infrastructure requirements for electricity and natural gas?

A: When comparing requirements, consider the availability of the electrical grid and natural gas pipelines, as well as the potential complexity and cost of upgrading your premises to meet your energy needs.